Plans to move mental health services out of Tottenham hospital slammed

15:00 15 March 2012

Paulette Case-Robinson at St Ann

Paulette Case-Robinson at St Ann's Hospital. Pic: Tony Gay.


Plans to close down vital mental health services in Haringey and relocate them several miles away in Enfield have been slammed as a return to the age of “asylums”, threatening to leave patients “isolated”.

The proposals to shut down all three in-patient wards at St Ann’s Hospital in St Ann’s Road, South Tottenham, and “consolidate” them with services on offer at Chase Farm Hospital in Enfield were set in motion on Tuesday.

This week the proposals by Barnet, Enfield and Haringey Mental Health NHS Trust (BEHMHT) were put under the microscope by service users in Haringey, medical practitioners, representatives from Haringey Council, and the National Clinical Advisory Team (NCAT).

Paulette Case-Robinson, a service user who lives near the hospital, said: “It seems as though the [NHS trust] is trying to recreate the asylums when they should be looking after people in their own communities.

“Under the plans, Haringey people would be isolated while they are being treated in hospital and then they have to come back to a community that they’ve been isolated from to try and fit in again.”

The review follows the endorsement of the plans last month by the Department of Health, which involved consultation with Tottenham MP David Lammy and BEHMHT chief executive Maria Kane, among others.

The relocation of the in-patient wards at St Ann’s is part of a wider project planned for the site, which the Journal understands includes a particular desire for housing.

A BEHMHT spokesman said the trust “would like to see a mixed-use development” on the site, which replaces “outdated buildings with new purpose-built health facilities”.

He added: “The trust is working closely with the council’s planning department to ensure any potential redevelopment benefits the community.”

If the proposals get the the go-ahead in the coming weeks by Dr Paul Winterbottom, who is leading the NCAT review, they will go on to a formal consultation before reaching the council’s planning committee.

Discussions about the regeneration of St Ann’s have been ongoing for years, but these latest developments signal the first steps towards redevelopment on the site.

In addition to the three in-patient wards, which have 45 beds, the hospital also runs an eating disorders unit, a 24-hour walk-in centre for those in crisis and is the base for the Home Treatment Team.

All of these services would be lost at St Ann’s should the plans be approved, ceasing all acute psychiatric in-patient care at the hospital.

But the BEHMHT spokesman insisted “talks are in their infancy”, adding: “There are convincing arguments for and against the move and our focus is on what is best for patients.”


Latest News Stories

Saturday, November 14, 2015
Police officers secure a street outside the Stade de France stadium (AP Photo/Michel Euler)

Following multiple terrorist attacks in Paris, this is advice for people who are either in France or who have friends or family on the continent.

Monday, October 12, 2015
Deborah Willemen said she felt like she had 'lost a limb' after the bike was stolen at 3am on Saturday morning (Picture: Deborah Willemen)

‘It was like losing a limb’: A Tottenham single mum needs your help after her life-altering cargobike was (ineptly) stolen by a thief in the dead of night.

Monday, October 12, 2015
Mario Madeo has been jailed

A teenager who carried out two armed robberies on fast food outlets in Willesden and Cricklewood on the same night has been jailed for seven years.

Tuesday, September 22, 2015
One Direction fans queue in the rain to see their idols later this evening. Picture: Twitter/@sweetlarryhugs

One Direction fans proved they will do almost anything to be first in line to see their popstar idols – even wait for hours in the rain on a gloomy day in Camden.

Most read news


MAC Makeup

MAC are renowned for their flawless, fabulous make up that is used worldwide by the stars. You too can have the chance to have the perfect makeup to suit your needs with £1,000 to spend on all the glam goodies you like!


You are never far from an Argos, wherever in the country you may be. They are like a magical cavern where whatever you need they seem to have it out the back behind the counter. So why not put them to the test with this great MyOffers competition to win £1000 to spend in-store.

Digital Edition

Read the Tottenham Journal e-edition today E-edition
Family Notices 24

Local business directory

Our trusted business finder